Narrow Rows

Planting - Narrow Row Corn

"If farmers are to consistently grow 300-bushel-per-acre corn or higher, we're going to have to do it in 12-in, 15-inch or 20-inch rows." – Marion Calmer

As the creator of the world's first single chain narrow row corn head in 1995, along with the world's largest (32 row, 12-inch) in 2013, Marion Calmer has been a trailblazer in the Ag industry when it comes to narrow row crops and the equipment that harvests them. As the President of Calmer Ag Research, the largest independently funded, farmer run Ag research center in the United States, Marion has conducted extensive research on various aspects of planting, growing and harvesting crops in narrow rows.

A Quote from Marion Calmer - Farmer, Researcher, and Inventor

"I have a passion for farming, and for improving the way I farm. I have farmed on my own since 1975, and I am always trying to become more profitable and environmentally friendly. I have found that narrow row corn is helping to achieve both goals. Bottom line: there is less soil erosion in the field, healthier plants, less weeds, better moisture and sunlight, and increased nutrient utilization. This ultimately results in higher yields, less chemicals, and more bottom line profit! I want everyone to learn the correct way to grow narrow row corn, and see that there really are significant and repeatable advantages! Please refer to the links below for detailed information on planting, growing, harvesting and researching narrow row crops or call me directly at (309) 368-1182."

Helpful Documents

The Bottom Line: Benefits of Growing Narrow Row Crops

Marion Calmer and Francis Childs
(Manchester, IA - World Record Corn Yield
441BU/AC - 20" Rows)

"All indications are that I should have
switched to 20" rows sooner!"
- Francis Childs

  • More bushels per acre
  • Less weeds
  • Less erosion
  • Plant and harvest faster
  • Bottom line: more profit

In 15" and 20" rows, plant spacing become more uniform and as a result, reduces in-row competition between plants and improves sunlight interception.

Row WidthPopulationAverage Plant Spacing
30"  at 28,000 =  7.5"
20"  at 28,000 =  11"
15"  at 28,000 =  15"

 

Side-By-Side Yield Comparisons 30" vs. 15" Rows

Based on farmer conducted research and experience, proper implementation of these row spacings will provide significantly higher yields than those of traditional 30-inch or greater row spacings.

Download a PDF detailing the yield comparisons.

 

Myths of 15 and 20-inch Row Corn

False  Research data from Texas actually shows a higher yield. True  Research data from Texas actually shows a higher yield advantage to 15-inch corn rows over 30-inch than does University of Illinois research data. Argentina and Brasil are way ahead of the United States in the adoption of narrow row corn.
False It takes a special hybrid to grow narrow row corn. True  Premier hybrids in wide rows tend to be Premier hybrids in 15 and 20-inch rows.
False  Narrow row corn requires narrow tires. True Research from Ohio State indicates wider tires have a bigger footprint thus reducing compaction and increasing yields.
False Seed costs increase in 15 and 20-inch rows due to higher populations. True Significant yield advantages have been documented even when both row spacings are compared at the same population.
False The yield advantage of 15 and 20-inch row corn is minimal. True In 394 side-by-side farmer field trials, 15-inch row corn outyielded 30-inch row corn by an average of 12.3 bushels per acre.

 

Hear Marion discuss his progression toward solid seeded corn over the years and explain why he sees the industry continuing to move toward narrower rows in the future.

 

Ultra-Narrow Row Corn Shows Yield Promise

Originally covered in Farm Forum, Spring 1997

The move from 40- and 38-inch row corn down to 30-inch rows is credited as one of the major factors contributing to the steady increase of corn yields over the past several decades, along with improved hybrids, and better herbicides and fertilizers. 

The next major breakthrough may be just over the horizon, if 15-inch "ultra-narrow row" corn fulfills its early promises of improved yields and weed control advantages, similar to the gains 15-inch soybeans have shown. 

There's a generally accepted rule of thumb among corn rsearchers that says you'll average a 1-bushel-per-acre yield increase with every inch of row spacing you decrease. While quite a few studies have focused on 20-inch corn, researchers involved with 15-inch corn see no reason to consider 20 inches as a self-imposed lower limit . 15-inch row corn, they say, offers the best balance of yield potential, weed control and harvesting ease. Marion Calmer is an Alpha, Illinois, farmer who operates his own 1,300 acre independent research center based on "real world" field trials. He is an enthusiastic proponent of ultra-narrow row. "We have been doing extensive work with ultra-narrow row corn and believe beyond the shadow of a doubt that 15-inch rows offer a yield advantage," says Calmer, who has grown 15-inch corn in field conditions for several years. 

Gord Scheifele, a research scientist at the Ridgetown College of Agricultural Technology in Ridgetown, Ontario, agrees. He says test plot evaluations show "significant incremental increases in yields" compared to 20-inch corn. Purdue studies acknowledge the potential for yield gains in the "bushel per row inch" range, although noting the more consistent yield responses to ultra-narrow row corn appera to ocur in the Northern Corn Belt.

"We had to use a factory corn head last year for a while due to combine problems and will never go away from them [choppers] again. The Chopper is more aggressive at sizing up residue, and there is less trash into the combine at harvest."

- Jeff Dahl, Orion, IL